ARGUMENT: The Defense Mechanism Behind Privilege and Why we Need to Learn to be Better

Mcintosh and Roose discuss big topics that we struggle with in our society today with privilege within race and all different types of difference. In Roose's article, "All Lives Matter", it discusses the issues at hand with the All Lives Matter argument in relation with the Black Lives Matter movement, and how the All Lives Matter movement is only meant to counteract the meaning and validity the Black Lives Matter movement is trying to have. Roose uses the example that when one brings up the fact they have not gotten their fair share of their meal, they only bring it up to mention that they haven't gotten their portion. When someone states, "well, everyone deserves their fair portion", it is meant to mean that there is no shortage of what you have (even if there is). As Roose states in his article, he makes a Nightcrawler reference and how Jake Gyllenhall's character is told to film the crimes against the affluent white people instead of those of the Latino/Black race, even though those happen much more often. This clearly is an epidemic, but why? What led it to get to this point? There is a clear problem in our defense to privilege and how we interact with it. We see this highlighted in how the All Lives Matter movement in itself. People can agree that black people are oppressed, yet people do not want to give up their own privilege to make it just. We see the same concept expressed and explained in Peggy Mcintosh’s article, where she explains that the defense that people have in their privilege is not intentional. The argument that Mcintosh has is that our privilege is so built into our culture, that we unconsciously use our privilege and do not realize the privilege as such. So, when men get a promotion over women they do not recognize it as a privilege, they recognize it as being a result of their hard work. Here, we see the issue at hand is that privilege is present, yet it is not clear and recognized since it is ingrained culturally in the privileged people. The concept of people being defensive brings up the issue of the All Lives Matter Movement. Here, we see how this ties into the Kozol article, and how these kids deal with all their differences In south Bronx New York, yet they make the best of it because it comes to be what they expect. People begin to be defensive of their privilege, and are at risk of losing some portion of their privilege in some way, despite the clear indifference and struggles of lower minority communities like we see in Kozol’s, “Amazing Grace” . Such as when some news coverage would take away from whites being shot and killed, the whites suddenly preach that the cases they care about are not covered nearly enough. 

Here is a hyperlink that discusses that issue in St. Louis, and how children are dying with no justice, which happens in many heavily black communities :https://www.vox.com/identities/2019/8/28/20837393/st-louis-black-children-shootings-reward-gun-violence

Here we see statistics on shootings in New York City by race in 2011:



We see the problems that White privilege brings again and again, yet we still have no answer, because people who have privilege feel they are entitled to it. The problem is rooted here, and will continue to the problem until people wake up, realize their privileges, and move forward trying to make the world more equal for everyone. 

Works used for this information: 

Image: https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2014/08/police-shootings-michael-brown-ferguson-black-men/

Comments

  1. i enjoy how much of your opinion you put into this and how well you address how we as white people are so quick to say yeah black people are judged and oppressed but we are slower in understanding our own privilege. we do not address our privilege until someone else tells us how privileged we actually are. and it is funny how when our privilege is brought up we get so offended about it. i also loved how you put in about promotions and how they differ from a mans world to a woman's world. it is so true that a man would assume they got a promotion due to their " hard work" when in reality it is just a biased decision off of a gender. also great picture to show how race effects gun violence and fire arm use.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really enjoyed your post and thought you did a great job expressing your opinion on the topic. I think it's important to realize how I fit into all of this because that it is something your post made me think about. I also really liked how you discussed people seeing how oppression is a factor in all of this, but they don't want to give anything up to change this. Another point you made that was great was how people become defensive when it comes to these issues. I agree with what you said and it is also something I have noticed on the topic. I also really loved your hyperlink on the issue in St. Louis. I think it was a great source and an excellent example of how these issues are playing a role in today's world.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Reflections: LGBTQ Youth, and the proper way to Address this Demographic

HYPERLINKS: Assessing the ESL Classroom (Collier's "Teaching Multilingual Children")

About me!