Extended Comments: Kahne & Wesheimer's "In the Service of What?" and connecting to Shaelyn's LGBT article
As we are supposed to all read our peers' articles, certain ones stick out to me as being extra relevant and important. Last week's LGBTQ articles really stuck out to me the most, and really are some of the most influential thoughts we can bring into our classroom setting. We want our classes to be welcoming, accepting, and diverse... and we see that these ideas especially equate well to the LGBTQ communities.
Shaelyn Fiske, one of our peers, had wrote about her cousin's experience with acceptance in her home life, and how it has not come easy with her cousin's relationship with her grandmother. This experience is one that we need to relate to our LGBTQ youth in our classroom, and how we need to create an accepting environment for our students (given that it is not always that way in their home life).
Shaelyn states: "I love my grandmother very much and she would do anything for her four granddaughters, but she struggles to accept that one of them is gay. My younger cousin, who is 15, has recently come out as being gay and has started to gravitate to wearing more masculine clothing. My grandmother is having a difficult time accepting this about my cousin, even though my grandmother loves her unconditionally. My grandmother does not like to discuss that my younger cousin is gay and she tries to encourage my younger cousin that she is not gay and to wear more feminine clothing. Upon reading the two articles, it made me think how invalid this must make my younger cousin feel and that she is marginalized by my grandmother, who does not discuss homosexuality or gender fluidity with her. I want my grandmother to read the articles try to understand what my younger cousin is feeling or thinking. "
Shaelyn Fiske, one of our peers, had wrote about her cousin's experience with acceptance in her home life, and how it has not come easy with her cousin's relationship with her grandmother. This experience is one that we need to relate to our LGBTQ youth in our classroom, and how we need to create an accepting environment for our students (given that it is not always that way in their home life).
Shaelyn states: "I love my grandmother very much and she would do anything for her four granddaughters, but she struggles to accept that one of them is gay. My younger cousin, who is 15, has recently come out as being gay and has started to gravitate to wearing more masculine clothing. My grandmother is having a difficult time accepting this about my cousin, even though my grandmother loves her unconditionally. My grandmother does not like to discuss that my younger cousin is gay and she tries to encourage my younger cousin that she is not gay and to wear more feminine clothing. Upon reading the two articles, it made me think how invalid this must make my younger cousin feel and that she is marginalized by my grandmother, who does not discuss homosexuality or gender fluidity with her. I want my grandmother to read the articles try to understand what my younger cousin is feeling or thinking. "
We see that our relationship to LGBTQ youth is a vital one that can really shape an individual for the rest of their life, and that is what we are in service for. We are in service to make individuals better. To make ourselves better. We are in service to make differences in people, in our communities. in people's lives.
I want to be the teacher that does more than just their job. I want to be the teacher and individual that my students feel important to. I want to be the person that people thank when they look back on how I shaped their lives. As a teacher, you're in service to educate but to also be someone's hero.
So when we take a closer look at service learning projects and making a difference in the community, take into account that you will be the source of difference often. So spread that into your classrooms and encourage them to make a difference in their community: for the foodless, homeless, drug addicted, struggling families... to be their hero. And tying this into your students' education, they are learning about the lesson at hand but also so much more. Such as how in Ms. Adam's seventh grade classroom in the article, "In the Service of What? The Politics of Service Learning", we see Ms. Adams shape a complete lesson around homelessness in the world and community. We see her bring in people from homelessness advocacy groups, and really teach her kids how they can make a difference.
Imagine if we did the same thing with LGBTQ advocates? Had more lessons of LGBTQ history and the problems that community faces? Our students would learn from school that this community is not bad and should be accepted more than they are. And now, we are in a more susceptible time to gay and queer rights, and have come a long way from where things were. But imagine if we build off of this stamina and eliminate the stigma completely? That is what we really should be fighting for in the educational world right now. We need to push our kids to be heroes, as you should be shooting to be a hero to those kids yourself.

I see the positive aspects of what you're saying here, and I admire and support your ideal of doing more than just your job. My take on the article was about whether one was going to just help out for the short-term (charity), or whether one was going to put their efforts into real societal change. I would argue that your ideas could in fact bring about change, just maybe not quickly. But I believe any efforts with a positive result speak for themselves, and since I believe the kind of commitment required for major change may be to much to ask of most folks, that your approach is still valid and a contribution that can't be dismissed.
ReplyDeleteGreat work! I like how you analyzed the article and brought in Shaelyn's point in the last post. The importance of the way we make our students feel is critical because we want them to feel safe. I really like the point you bought up when you said you want the students to come back and thank you for inspiring them. The only way to get that outcome is to make sure that we make them welcomed and safe!
ReplyDelete