ARGUMENT: The Key to our Students' Success Lies in No Existing Town Lines.

Ae we have seen consistently as students our whole lives, there are three tiers of schools: Upper class, middle class, and poor. This is simply because of where they are their lines for the towns' public schools, and the upper class don't extend their lines past their upper class communities. While there are schools now that cannot discriminate against a specific race, in a way that it still what happens today.

As we hear in the "This American Life" #562, the key to closing this gap is being able to be closed simply through being around students that come from better schools then themselves... in integrating the poor students into the richer school systems. In poorer schools and segregated black schools, we see the poor accessibility to educational opportunity, including poorer facilities, less qualified teachers, everyone is behind, and limited advanced courses because of everyone being behind.

Just as there is a greater likelihood that if one runner, who is not the best but not terrible, will improve only when matched against a better runner, has a better coach, and has the facilities they need. Not saying that the same runner would not approve with other circumstances, but they will not succeed without proper competition, proper facilities, proper equipment, and proper coaching... we will not see this runner reach their best ability.

We see the counterargument that in integrating our schools, especially when unasked for, there is backlash from the upper class, white communities that ultimately want their schools to isolated and alone. Black and minority children see the brunt forces of social backlash as it is, never mind when they are really not supposed to be where they are. We see the backlash in the "This American Life" #562 and the backlash that we see against the black communities in the white schools. We see Howe school parents in Minnesota, being as racist and hurtful towards the black communities. But in integrating the schools, white parents do not need to be happy. We see that we need to push against the white backlash to make sure that EVERYONE has a proper access to upperclass education.  WE need to push forward like we did when Brown v. Board was passed. That was the point. The issue is the racism problem, despite how much parents make it seem. We see parents stating it is not a race issue, when the problem is that segregation is still present, and people assume black and underprivileged students are bad and violent. Yet, all we have seen from successful integration is that of done properly, the only thing that comes of it is rising test scores in African-American and minority students, which otherwise would not have happened.

Simply, no matter what articles you read or podcasts you hear, the problem with integration comes from the mere aspect that if test scores go down, it is because whites have left. allowing students from lower income communities, black, white and in between... will increase our educational standing which has only been on a steep decline in the past couple years. We see in the articles we had to read including the Hebert, "separate but equal"... that the problem here is that we are remaining separate and unequal despite what we otherwise should be progressively and aggressively working towards.

Brown v. Board Website, showing separate is not equal

The hyperlink above shows the meaning behind the Brown V. Board case, and that separate is not equal... yet look where we are at today? WE are in the same place as the civil rights movement in terms of education. That is simply a disgrace to even say aloud.

As teachers and educators, if we realize and acknowledge this problem and fight for intergration, or work on making the minority schools great, we will see a difference. While the minority schools may not be a place one wants to work.. stay and make more of an impact instead of more money. We need to find a solution, and while intergration is the best step forward (but may take a while), we need to fix what is in place while we wait for the best case scenario. Extend our love across borders until the schools do so, then our educational system will be in a more just position. 

It can't be so difficult to get an education and succeed, or else what is the point of having a public education system? The upper class would pay for the private schooling, and the minority children and the poor will suffer. This problem is one of the largest we may face as teachers, so we need to discuss and plan and execute a proper way to solve this issue.

Comments

  1. Great post Grace! I used your post for an extended comments post on my blog. You did a great job with your arguments post and I loved your organization with it. Nice work!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good stuff Grace, I really enjoyed your post. I thought you made a good point with your analogy about runners improving when pitted against better runners, given better coaching, and having access to better facilities. It's so true. I've been teaching musicians for over 30 years, and my advice to the younger players is always to play with older and better musicians because they will grow by leaps and bounds, just as I did when I was young and on the road for the first time.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great job this week! I like that you chose to do your post based upon the main argument of the interview. I think the picture you chose really highlights the key messages that the author was conveying throughout the episode. I think your own example of the runner was a great analogy to showcase the main ideas within the episode. I also agree that educators need to work in these low income schools, in order to help lessen the education gap between races and economic standings. Overall, I think you did an excellent job this week and did a great job showcasing the argument in the episode!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Reflections: LGBTQ Youth, and the proper way to Address this Demographic

HYPERLINKS: Assessing the ESL Classroom (Collier's "Teaching Multilingual Children")

About me!