REFLECTIONS: Shor's "Empowering Education: Critical Teaching for Social Change"
In Shor's article, we see the social approach to education and how it has a strong impact on students right away. But how? Well.... what is kid's relationship to school? How do they interact with school? Why is it important? These are all questions commonly asked, yet there is no definite answer. The primary issue at hand is that ultimately- what is the student teacher relationship in the classroom that leads us to the overall structure of the school system? This is an important a and key concept in seeing out students' relationship with school as a whole.
Shor states on page 12 of her article that many classroom and school set ups are based around the idea that there is a clear setup: the teacher leads and the students follow. Yet, the unfortunate idea that comes with this is that students are taught, they listen to information, then there is a test on what they supposed to have learned. But as we have seen in Rita Pierson's Ted Talk (which can be seen in my reflection on LGBTQ youth article), that the key to success, coming from successful teachers, is that there is an emotional connection in the classroom between student and teacher. This connection will not be seen if students go to class, just listen, take a test, and go home. So clearly the problem we can assess from this is that there is a need for change and reform in our education classroom setups and structure.
Here are some examples that Shor gives to help give examples of the ways to change the classroom dynamic:
"In a curriculum that encourages student questioning, the teacher avoids a unilateral transfer of knowledge. She or he helps students develop their intellectual and emotional powers to examine their learning in school, their everyday experience, and the conditions in society." (12)
This reflects the concepts that asking questions rather than direct teaching and listening, asking questions creates a much different dynamic in the classroom. By having to ask questions, students often reflect on what they know and don't know, their personal experiences, and how they connect to the topic, society, or general sense of self. This concept is something we can definitely and should definitely consider in thinking about how we want to teach our students in the future.
"Free public schooling and low-cost mass higher education are often celebrated as triumphs of democracy. Why, then, does the traditional curriculum in these institutions tilt towards authority rather than to freedom, participation, and mutuality?" (18)
This point emphasizes what is encouraged in the classroom, yet the fact that our teaching has basically been hypocritical to this point. With a teacher as an authority rather than a peer just encouraging knowledge, we see more of a dictatorship than a democracy. Encouraging discussion, collaboration, and a quality independent work, we students being prompted to be apart of the classroom than merely in it. This dynamic not only creates a better environment in the classroom, but better people of the greater democratic society.
Personally, I could see this difference in my own classrooms when I was in high school especially. You see the difference in a classroom when students are active and involved and always feel welcome in a classroom, rather than one that is just a teacher lecturing to her students. Seriously, Shor's point here is to change the dynamic to the one that is proven to work... so as future teachers, we should listen and pay attention.
Shor states on page 12 of her article that many classroom and school set ups are based around the idea that there is a clear setup: the teacher leads and the students follow. Yet, the unfortunate idea that comes with this is that students are taught, they listen to information, then there is a test on what they supposed to have learned. But as we have seen in Rita Pierson's Ted Talk (which can be seen in my reflection on LGBTQ youth article), that the key to success, coming from successful teachers, is that there is an emotional connection in the classroom between student and teacher. This connection will not be seen if students go to class, just listen, take a test, and go home. So clearly the problem we can assess from this is that there is a need for change and reform in our education classroom setups and structure.
Here are some examples that Shor gives to help give examples of the ways to change the classroom dynamic:"In a curriculum that encourages student questioning, the teacher avoids a unilateral transfer of knowledge. She or he helps students develop their intellectual and emotional powers to examine their learning in school, their everyday experience, and the conditions in society." (12)
This reflects the concepts that asking questions rather than direct teaching and listening, asking questions creates a much different dynamic in the classroom. By having to ask questions, students often reflect on what they know and don't know, their personal experiences, and how they connect to the topic, society, or general sense of self. This concept is something we can definitely and should definitely consider in thinking about how we want to teach our students in the future.
"Free public schooling and low-cost mass higher education are often celebrated as triumphs of democracy. Why, then, does the traditional curriculum in these institutions tilt towards authority rather than to freedom, participation, and mutuality?" (18)
This point emphasizes what is encouraged in the classroom, yet the fact that our teaching has basically been hypocritical to this point. With a teacher as an authority rather than a peer just encouraging knowledge, we see more of a dictatorship than a democracy. Encouraging discussion, collaboration, and a quality independent work, we students being prompted to be apart of the classroom than merely in it. This dynamic not only creates a better environment in the classroom, but better people of the greater democratic society.
Personally, I could see this difference in my own classrooms when I was in high school especially. You see the difference in a classroom when students are active and involved and always feel welcome in a classroom, rather than one that is just a teacher lecturing to her students. Seriously, Shor's point here is to change the dynamic to the one that is proven to work... so as future teachers, we should listen and pay attention.
Grace, yet again, great post! I always like how you start off your blog entries, they always introduce the topic very nicely and pull me in. You made a very nice connection with Pierson's ted talk. I hadn't thought about how the articles related before reading your blog, but now that you brought it up I can see that some of the ideas tie hand in hand with one another. You need to made personal connections with your students and by doing this, they need to feel welcomed and participate. You picked effective quotes that capture the ideas of the article nicely, and I like how you ended your blog with your own thoughts of how you could relate your high school days to this article. Well done :)
ReplyDeleteYour blog post started off with a great hook and that got me excited to read it. I was very interested to read about the reflections you included into this post. The quotes you chose perfectly encapsulated the points you were making. As always your blog posts are coherent and well thought through. Great job!
ReplyDeleteGrace, great post. I completely agree with you (& Shor) that changing the style of teaching by asking questions instead of direct teaching and having the students just listen positively changes the dynamic of the classroom. Speaking from my own experiences, classes that I just sit, listen and don't have the opportunity to participate in are usually the hardest for me to connect too which inevitable makes it harder!
ReplyDelete